Recusals

Below is the list of the 62 instances where Raj Salwan has had to recuse himself from voting on an issue as a City Councilmember and Planning Commissioner due to his property holdings and campaign contributions he has received. Does Fremont want a Mayor that can’t even vote on many matters because they own so much land in Fremont?

It should also be noted that Councilmembers and the Mayor vote on citywide issues such as rental ordinances and development fees. As a landlord and major landowner, he can benefit financially from these citywide decisions. One could easily argue that people with a significant financial interest in the outcome should not be allowed to vote on these citywide decisions.

Note that two of the recusals were done when he was on the Planning Commission. He had to recuse himself from voting on the Henkel development in Niles and the Warm Springs / South Fremont Community Plan due to campaign contributions he received from the developers of those projects. Oddly, as a Councilmember you can directly take a contribution from a developer, and then vote for one of their developments. You can’t take a contribution over $250 as a Planning Commissioner and then vote on one of their projects.*

*In 2022 the law changed so that this requirement now applies to City Councilmembers as well (SB 1439).

Date Issue Recusal Reason
3/5/2013 Warm Springs / South Fremont Community Meeting Property holdings
6/18/2013 42410 Palm Avenue Property holdings
9/17/2013 Centerville Unified Site Remediation Services Property holdings
4/8/2014 Service Agreement with TRC Engineers, Inc. Property holdings
7/22/2014 Warm Springs/South Fremont Community Plan Property holdings
7/22/2014 General Plan Amendment for South Fremont Property holdings
9/9/2014 Warm Spring / South Fremont Master Fee Schedule Update Property holdings
2/12/2015 (Planning Commission) Warm Springs / South Fremont Community Plan Property holdings
2/12/2015 (Planning Commission) Henkle Development Campaign Contributions
12/20/2016 Final map for 44960 Warm Springs Blvd. Property holdings
6/6/2017 Warm Springs BART West Access Bridge and Plaza Project Property holdings
6/6/2017 Master Plan for development in Warm Springs Property holdings
9/5/2017 Warm Springs BART West Access Bridge and Plaza Project Property holdings
9/12/2017 Remediation Services at the Centerville Unified site Property holdings
10/17/2017 Warm Springs Public Facilities Property holdings
11/21/2017 Formation of CFD No. 2 and Incur Bond Indebtedness Property holdings
11/21/2017 Issuance of Bonds for CFD No. 2 Property holdings
11/21/2017 Levying Special Taxes in CFD No. 2 Property holdings
12/5/2017 Community Facilities District No. 2 Property holdings
2/6/2018 Historic Centerville Pioneer Cemetary Property holdings
2/20/2018 37218 Fremont Boulevard Rezoning, second reading Property holdings
3/20/2018 Centerville Train Depot Paid Parking Program Property holdings
4/3/2018 Centerville Train Depot Paid Parking Program, second reading Property holdings
5/1/2018 Pedestrian Overcrossing at Warm Springs BART Property holdings
5/15/2018 Warm Springs Public Services CFD No. 3 Property holdings
6/19/2018 Warm Springs Public Services CFD No. 3 Property holdings
9/8/2018 Centerville Unified Site Located at 37070 Fremont Boulevard Property holdings
5/7/2019 Centerville Train Depot Paid Parking Program Property holdings
5/7/2019 Summarily vacate various city rights-of-way Property holdings
6/18/2019 Issuance and Sale of Special Tax Bonds Property holdings
7/16/2019 Irvington BART Station Area Plan Property holdings
10/1/2019 Amending Fremont Municipal Code Sections 18.165.080, … Property holdings
12/10/2019 Warm Springs/South Fremont Community Plan Property holdings
1/14/2020 Development at 45388 Warm Springs Boulevard Property holdings
3/27/2020 Regulations related to evictions of small-scale commercial tenants Property holdings
5/5/2020 Request to delay minimum wage increase Property holdings
7/21/2020 Irvington BART Station Project Property holdings
9/1/2020 Public easement at at 45500 Fremont Boulevard Property holdings
9/1/2020 Faithful Performance Bond Posted by Lennar Homes Property holdings
9/1/2020 Faithful Performance Bond Posted by Lennar Homes Property holdings
9/15/2020 Landscape Maintenance Services for Innovation Plaza Property holdings
9/15/2020 Toll Brothers’ Metro Crossing Urban Plaza Property holdings
10/13/2020 City Council consider formally endorsing California Proposition 15 Property holdings
12/8/2020 Dedication of Public Easements for Tract 8465 Property holdings
1/12/2021 COVID-19 Rapid Response Grant Property holdings
2/16/2021 Agreement with New Image Landscape Company Property holdings
4/13/2021 Fremont Boulevard Safe and Smart Corridor Project Property holdings
5/4/2021 Permanent Public Art Installation Within Warm Springs Plaza Property holdings
5/4/2021 Restructure and Reassess Landscaping Assessment District 88 Property holdings
7/13/2021 Resolution Declaring the abandonment of Proceedings for the Restructure and Reassessment of the Fremont Landscaping District 88 Property holdings
7/20/2021 Fremont Boulevard Traffic Signal Modernization Property holdings
9/21/2021 Consulting and Administrative Services for District 88 Property holdings
10/12/2021 Construction Contract to Bear Electrical Solutions, Inc. Property holdings
12/14/2021 Creating Train Horn Quiet Zones Property holdings
2/8/2022 Street Design Along Fremont Boulevard Property holdings
3/1/2022 Warm Springs BART West Access Bridge and Plaza Project Property holdings
6/7/2022 Annual Assessments for Landscaping Assessment District 88 Property holdings
10/4/2022 Metro West Development Project Property holdings
11/1/2022 Metro West Phase 2 Development Project Property holdings
2/21/2023 Centerville Complete Streets Project Property holdings
3/14/2023 Landscaping Assessment District 88 for Fiscal Year 2023/24 Property holdings
5/9/2023 Centerville Unified Site Property holdings
5/9/2023 Fremont Landscaping Assessment District 88 Property holdings
5/9/2023 Senior Commission Appointment Relative being appointed
9/19/2023 Centerville Railroad Corridor Safety Improvement Project Property holdings